Refund Policy
Cookies are perishable, so we don't accept returns the way a regular store does. But if anything we sent you isn't right — broken, stale, the wrong order, never arrived — tell us within 48 hours and we'll make it right.
1. Quality & freshness
Every order is hand-packed and freshness-stamped by a real human. If your cookies arrive stale, broken beyond a few crumbs, or otherwise not the way they should be:
- Email hello@dutchmanscookies.com within 48 hours of delivery
- Include your order number and a photo of the issue
- We'll replace the affected items or refund them — your call
2. Wrong order
If we shipped the wrong cookies or missed an item, we'll bake what you ordered and send it out the next bake day at no charge. You don't need to return the wrong cookies — eat them, gift them, share them.
3. Damaged in shipping
We pack cookies carefully, but shipping carriers have their moments. If a box arrives crushed or your cookies are pulverized:
- Photograph the box and the cookies before unpacking further
- Email us within 48 hours
- We'll file the carrier claim on our end and ship a replacement on the next bake day
4. Never arrived
If your tracking shows delivered but you can't find the box, check with neighbors and your mail carrier first. If it's truly missing after 24 hours, email us and we'll work it out — usually with a replacement and a carrier claim.
5. Cancellation window
We bake fresh, so we lock orders into the production schedule the day before they ship.
- Retail orders — can be cancelled until 2 PM the day before your scheduled bake day, full refund
- After the bake day starts, the order is in the oven and we can't cancel — but the quality guarantee above still applies once it arrives
6. Catering orders
Catering follows a different timeline because we order ingredients and reserve oven time in advance:
- 7+ days before event — full refund, no questions asked
- 3–7 days before — 50% refund (we've already started buying ingredients)
- Less than 3 days — non-refundable; we can sometimes reschedule, ask us
7. Wholesale orders
Wholesale terms are governed by your wholesale agreement. In general: quality issues on a delivered case are credited against your next invoice. Cancellations follow the lead-time on your agreement (usually 48 hours for direct, 7 days for distribution).
8. How refunds are issued
Refunds go back to the original payment method. Stripe refunds usually post within 5–10 business days, though it can be faster. We'll send an email when the refund is on its way. Wholesale credits appear on your next invoice unless you request a check refund instead.
9. What we can't refund
- Cookies that arrived fine and were eaten before you decided you didn't like them
- Address corrections after the order has shipped (we'll forward the package at cost when carrier allows)
- Catering deposits inside the 3-day window (see §6)
- Gift orders for which the recipient is unreachable (we'll hold the shipment for 7 days, then it's on the giver)
10. Contact
Email hello@dutchmanscookies.com with your order number, or call (435) 673-6425 during shop hours.